Skip to main content

The Poverty of Puritanism


A candid and honest appraisal of Islamic intellectual history will no doubt reveal how much this tradition has been influenced by the surrounding intellectual milieu. But for over-zealous adherents who claim to ‘purify’ the entire tradition from any external accretions, to return the religion as it were to its pristine purity unadulterated by any ‘outside’ influences, the whole religion must be kept strictly self-referential. That means all that savors of Islam must be identifiable back to the Qur’an (and Sunnah) alone. If indeed there are elements of, say, Greek, Hellenistic, Hindu, Jewish or Christian origins in the tradition, this must be replaced with an entire system based squarely on the Qur’an. In doing so, what the so-called ‘reformists’ have done, unbeknownst to them, is to replace a system of intellectual inquiry made up of hundreds, if not thousands of learned men and women, with a new-born ‘system’ born of the narrow confines of their own ego.

Comments

afiqjohari said…
Have you written any books by chance?

December 17, 2012 at 6:56 AM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Conscience of the Market

When we say that the market should be restrained by ethical norms we don’t by default mean that the state should carry that responsibility. Critics typically take as axiomatic that the market is the root of all evil that any instance of irregularity, deficiency or oppressive practices that occur in commercial contexts is taken to warrant immediate outside intervention; and by that is often meant the state. Such an assumption about the market seriously underestimates the possibility of the market itself in restraining its own excesses. The misplaced emphasis on developing measures external to the market to rectify the latter’s shortcomings has only the result of treating the symptom rather than the real disease.
Post a Comment
Read more

Al-Attas on 'Islamic civilization'

Syed Muhammad Naquib al-Attas’s definition of ‘Islamic civilization’: “I define Islamic civilization as a civilization that emerges among the diversity of cultures of Muslim peoples of the world as a result of the permeation of the basic elements of the religion of Islam which those peoples have caused to emerge from within themselves. The process by which such emergence comes about is called Islamization, which is the liberation first from magical, mythical, animistic and ethnic cultural tradition incompatible with Islam, and then from secular control over one’s reason and one’s language. Whatever basic and praiseworthy elements of the pre-Islamic civilization that bind people together and are accepted as compatible with Islam become part of Islamic civilization. It is a living civilization whose pulse describes a process of Islamization, not in the dialectical sense of an evolutionary ‘development’, but in the sense of a progress involving every generation of Muslim towards r...
Post a Comment
Read more

Liberalism's flaw - the 'contingency' of freedom

One serious error in liberal articulation of freedom and human rights lies in its contingent theory of freedom. That is to say, liberalism posits freedom as the absence of state intrusion into the private lives of individuals: freedom is contingent on such omission by the state, barring which the individual is denied his freedom. At its basic and most fundamental level, it is a recognition that the state has the ability to undermine the freedom of the individual. The state is thus unduly given the power to decide and determine the freedom of the individual. This is grotesquely false for freedom is ultimately secured deep within the soul and it is so powerful that no one save God is able to take it away from the individual. In conceiving of freedom in the socio-political sense, liberal philosophers have practically mutilated it and truncated it beyond recognition such that ‘freedom’ is now given an exclusively narrow and limited province, robbing it off the vastness and richness that ...
Post a Comment
Read more